An Uncommon Ice Cream Experience Uniquely Served
Who We Are
Uncommon Cups and Cones is a locally owned, cozy, eclectic ice cream shop filled with antiques and serving flavorful ice cream in teacups and cones located in New Albany, Indiana. We are open year-round.
We have a semi-private room (The Upper Room) which is best for small gatherings of 12-15. Perfect for book clubs, team meetings, showers, study groups and celebrations.
Have an event coming up? Let us cater your wedding, parties or any get together!
Our Menu
Our menu includes scoops of ice cream served in Cups and Cones, Classic and Brownie sundaes, Floats and other Specialties, such as Banana Splits, Flight (8 flavor sampling) and Ice Cream Nachos, just to name a few.
We also have pints, chocolate covered bananas, Ice Cream Tacos and more available in our Grab 'n Go freezer.
(Menu items and prices are subject to change at any time.)
Today's Flavors
- We proudly serve Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream and offer a unique selection of 28 super premium, hand-dipped flavors including seasonal and Dairy Free, Vegan options (subject to change at any time).
- Today’s Flavors: Zanzibar Chocolate, Old Fashioned Vanilla, Butter Pecan, This Stuff Just Got Serious, Fat Elvis, Exhausted Parent, Iced Latte Da, Munchie Madness, Kitty Kitty Bang Bang, Strawberry, Cherry Chocolate Chip, Chocolate, Lemon Meringue, Blackberry Lemon Bar, Mint Avalanche, Super Human, Banana Cream Pie, Blueberry Cheesecake, Ultimate Oreo, Raspberry Rhapsody, Yippee Skippee, Me Want Cookie, Matcha Green Tea, Orange Sherbet
- Dairy Free, Vegan: Black Cherry Oat Cream, Vanilla Oat Cream, Strawberry Hibiscus Italian Ice
- No Sugar Added (NSA): NSA Pomegranate Swirl
CATERING AND RENTAL OPTIONS AVAILABLE
Want to make your next birthday party or celebration even sweeter? Contact us about reserving our Ice Cream Cooler filled with 1 scoop cups that are quick and easy to pass out. Or, if you want to scoop yourself, try renting our Ice Cream Crock set.
Click on our Catering tab for more info.
Come Find Us in UPTOWN New Albany!
We're located in Uptown New Albany at 518 Vincennes Street next to the former Honey Creme Donut Shop and a few blocks from New Albany High School.
We are sandwiched between two Uptown murals. This mural is located at the corner of Spring and Vincennes Streets. Turn right here, and you'll find us before you get to the next one.
Our Shop
Upon entering you immediately notice we are UNCOMMON
Try our Flight. Sharing is optional! YUM!
We make Banana Splits customized with your chosen flavors and toppings.
Add a delicious, warm brownie to your Sundae. You choose the ice cream and topping, then it's covered in whipped cream, nuts and a cherry!
The Upper Room seats 12-15 guests comfortably and is available to reserve for any get together without charge, if more than half of the attendees will be getting products from our shop. Or, $25/hour for room only.
Organizers may bring in outside food and drinks and come 1 hour early to decorate. (No confetti or glitter, please.)
Contact us to check availability.
NOTE: Due to seasonality, reservation
Hot Chocolate Float...perfect for those colder days.
Show More