Uncommon Cups and Cones * 518 Vincennes Street * New Albany, IN 47150
Welcome to an Uncommon Ice Cream Shop
An Uncommon Ice Cream Experience Uniquely Served
Who We Are
Uncommon Cups and Cones is a locally owned, cozy, eclectic ice cream shop. Filled with antiques and serving flavorful ice cream in tea cups and cones. We are open all year round, offering coffee, hot chocolate, apple cider and a variety of hot teas.
We have a semi-private room (The Upper Room) which holds about 15-18 people and is great for meetings, showers, study groups and parties.
Let us cater your wedding, parties or any get together!
Ice Cream makes everything better!
Our Flavors
We offer a unique selection of Super Premium, hand-dipped ice creams including seasonal selections and the classics.
Dairy Free options are also available.
(Flavors are subject to change at any time.)
Our Menu
Our menu includes scoops of ice cream served in Cups and Cones, Classic and Brownie sundaes, Floats and other Specialties, such as Banana Splits, Flight (8 flavor sampling) and Ice Cream Nachos, just to name a few.
We also have pints available in our Grab 'n Go freezer.
(Menu items and prices are subject to change at any time.)
Come Find Us
We're located in the New Albany UPTOWN area at 518 Vincennes Street between Honey Creme Donut Shop and New Albany High School.
Our Place
Upon entering you immediately notice we are UNCOMMON
Try our Flight. Sharing is optional! YUM!
Offering 28 Fabulous Flavors, including seasonal and dairy free options
Add a delicious, warm brownie to your Sundae. You choose the ice cream and topping, then it's covered in whipped cream, nuts and a cherry!
The Upper Room seats approximately 15-18 people and is available to reserve for any get together.
There is no charge for the room if more than 1/2 the attendees will be getting our products. Organizers can bring in outside food and drinks and come 1 hour early to decorate.
If the group needs the room only, then it is $25 per hour to reserve.
Please call the shop at 812.924.7047 or send us an email at
Hot Chocolate Float...perfect for those colder days.
Show More